Duane Buziak

Duane Buziak
Mortgage Maestro | NMLS #1110647 | Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC
Licensed Mortgage Broker serving Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, Georgia, and Washington, specializing in VA home loans and first-time homebuyer programs.

Suppose you owe $320,000 at 7.0% with 28 years (336 months) left, and a lender quotes 6.0% on a new 30-year loan. Your principal and interest payment drops from about $2,175 to about $1,919, a saving of $256 a month. If closing costs are $7,000, you break even in month 28. After five years you are about $8,360 ahead (60 months times $256 is $15,360, minus $7,000). If you sell or refinance again at month 24, you finish roughly $860 behind. This is an illustration, but the lesson holds for real loans: the rate alone never tells you which outcome you will get.

Fees, term, and timing decide it. A refinance comparison worksheet puts the loan you have and every offer you hold in side-by-side columns, so each option reduces to one honest number. Duane Buziak uses seven ways of working that sheet, and each one catches a different kind of bad deal.

By Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647. All dollar figures below are labelled illustrations; your own numbers will differ, so recompute them with your statement and your Loan Estimates.

On this page

1. Lock In Your Current Loan Baseline

Every quote you collect gets judged against one column, so that column has to be accurate before anything else goes on the sheet. Without it, “savings” means whatever a lender’s estimate of your current payment says it means. Your own statement is the only honest benchmark.

Take the illustration from the opening: $320,000 at 7.0% with 336 months left. The principal and interest payment works out to about $2,175. Multiply that by 336 and you get roughly $730,800 in remaining payments. Subtract the $320,000 balance and about $410,800 of interest is still ahead of you. That is the figure every refinance has to beat, or at least explain.

  1. Pull your latest mortgage statement or open your servicer portal.
  2. In column one, enter the current principal balance, interest rate, months remaining, monthly principal and interest, escrow amount, and any monthly mortgage insurance.
  3. Compute payment times months remaining, then subtract the balance. That is your remaining interest.
  4. Keep escrow on its own row. Taxes and homeowners insurance usually carry over to a new loan, so they should not be counted as savings, but they belong in the total payment line.

The most common mistake is using the original loan terms or a figure remembered from closing day. Your balance has fallen and your months remaining have shrunk, so a 30-year schedule from years ago will overstate both the interest you still owe and the savings a new loan seems to offer. A related error is folding escrow into the payment comparison, which makes a change in your tax or insurance bill look like refinance savings.

What to measure: baseline monthly principal and interest and baseline remaining interest. If mortgage insurance is on the statement, give it its own row too, since removing it is a separate saving you can price on the sheet.

2. Compare Offers Using the Same Loan Estimate Fields

Two lenders can quote the same rate and charge very different amounts to deliver it. The Loan Estimate is the standardized form lenders use to disclose rate, payment, and costs, which means every quote can be transcribed onto identical rows. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains how each page is laid out, and the layout is what makes a line-by-line comparison possible.

Consider an illustration: two quotes at 6.0% with nearly identical monthly payments. Page 1 looks the same. On page 2, one quote carries $1,800 more in origination charges. At $256 a month in savings, that extra $1,800 pushes break-even out by about seven months, and you would never see it by comparing rates.

  1. Request Loan Estimates on the same day, for the same loan amount, lock period, credit score, and loan-to-value (LTV) ratio. LTV is your loan balance divided by your home’s value.
  2. Transcribe the rate, APR, and points, then Section A (origination charges), Section B (services you cannot shop for), and Section C (services you can shop for).
  3. Highlight the lender-controlled fees in Section A. Third-party fees such as appraisal and title tend to be similar across lenders; origination fees and points are where quotes diverge.
  4. Record the lock period and the date of each quote on its own row.

Watch for headline rates compared across different days or lock periods. Rates move daily, and a 15-day lock is not priced like a 45-day lock. Also keep the weekly Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey in context: it is a national average of surveyed loans, useful for tracking direction, but it is not a quote for your credit profile and should never go in an offer column.

What to measure: total closing costs, lender-controlled fees, and APR for each quote. A lower rate paired with a higher APR often signals heavier fees.

3. Run the Break-Even Month Calculation

The break-even month is the point at which your cumulative monthly savings equal what you paid to refinance. Before that month, you are behind; after it, you are ahead. The formula is simple: out-of-pocket costs divided by monthly savings.

In an illustration, $6,500 in costs divided by $190 in monthly savings gives about 34 months. If you expect to stay in the loan for 10 years, that is an easy yes. If you plan to relocate in two, it is a clear no, regardless of how attractive the rate looks.

The trap sits in costs that are rolled into the loan. They do not disappear; they raise your balance and your payment. In the same illustration, adding $6,500 to a 30-year loan at 6.0% increases the payment by about $39 a month. If the $190 saving was calculated before that, the real saving is closer to $151, and break-even stretches to about 43 months. Rolling costs in lowers what you pay at the closing table, but it still counts against you.

  1. Add a row for each option: total costs (including any rolled in), true monthly savings against your baseline, and break-even months.
  2. Add a final row for how many years you realistically expect to keep the home or the loan.
  3. Convert years to months and compare. Break-even well inside your holding period passes; break-even near or beyond it fails.

A frequent mistake is leaving the “expected years” row blank, which turns the calculation into an abstract number. Be honest here: job changes, growing families, and planned upgrades all shorten holding periods.

What to measure: break-even months for each offer, set against your planned time in the loan. A margin of at least a year or two gives you protection if plans change.

4. Weigh Rate Against Points

Discount points are fees paid at closing to lower the interest rate, with one point equal to 1% of the loan amount. They are a bet that you will keep the loan long enough for the lower payment to repay the up-front cost. The worksheet turns that bet into a number.

On a $320,000 loan, one point costs $3,200. In an illustration where that point cuts the payment by $60 a month, $3,200 divided by $60 is about 53 months. Keep the loan for four and a half years or more and the point pays off. Leave earlier and you have simply donated money to the lender.

The useful move is to compare quotes in pairs rather than all at once. Ask for the same loan at three price points:

Then compute the incremental break-even between each neighboring pair. Suppose the lender-credit version costs $4,000 in total and its payment runs $45 higher than the zero-point quote. Moving from credit to zero points costs $3,000 more and saves $45 a month, which is about 67 months. Moving from zero points to one point is the 53-month case above. Laying out those two numbers shows exactly how long each step demands.

The mistake to avoid is paying points on a loan you are likely to sell or refinance within a few years. If rates drop again, or you move, the points go unrecovered. For that situation the lender-credit row often wins.

What to measure: incremental break-even months for each point purchased, compared with how long you expect to hold the loan.

5. Add the Term-Reset Test

A term reset happens when you refinance into a new loan whose term starts over, which can stretch repayment well past the years you had left. Monthly payment relief feels like progress, but the interest total can tell a different story.

Suppose a different homeowner owes $320,000 at 7.0% with 22 years remaining. Payment is about $2,379, with roughly $308,000 of interest left. Refinancing to a new 30-year at 6.0% drops the payment to about $1,919, a $460 monthly cut, yet total interest rises to roughly $370,700 and payoff slips eight years. A 20-year at 6.0% runs about $2,293, still $86 below the current payment, with about $230,200 in total interest and payoff two years earlier than today.

  1. Add rows for total interest paid and payoff date for each option.
  2. Add the closing costs to total interest to get the all-in cost of each path.
  3. Model the 30-year with extra principal: pay the new loan at your old payment of about $2,379. In this illustration the loan clears in about 224 months, near 18.7 years, with roughly $212,000 in interest, ahead of the 22-year schedule.

That last row is useful because it shows the flexibility of a longer term. You get the lower required payment as a safety net, and you choose whether to keep paying the higher amount.

The common mistake is celebrating a lower payment without checking total interest. Lower monthly cost is real value for a tight budget, but it should be a conscious trade, not a surprise at year 20.

What to measure: total interest paid and payoff date versus the current loan, with closing costs included.

6. Price Cash-Out and HELOC on the Same Sheet

If you want cash from your equity, you have two structures to compare: replace the whole mortgage with a larger cash-out loan, or keep the existing first mortgage and add a second lien such as a home equity line of credit (HELOC). The right answer depends on the rate on your current loan, which is why a single sheet matters.

A blended rate is the weighted average of every loan against the home. In an illustration, you hold a $250,000 first mortgage at 3.5% and add a $50,000 HELOC at 8.5%. The blended rate is about 4.33%, and first-year interest comes to roughly $13,000. A new 6.5% cash-out refinance on $300,000 produces about $19,500 of first-year interest. With a low first-mortgage rate, keeping it and borrowing the extra separately often wins. With a high first rate, the math flips.

  1. Add a column for cash-out and a column for HELOC, beside your baseline.
  2. Compute the blended rate, total monthly payment, and closing costs for each path.
  3. Check LTV limits. Conventional cash-out refinances cap at 90% LTV, so a $500,000 home allows up to $450,000 in total loan. VA cash-out refinances can reach 100% LTV; see VA cash-out loan guidance for eligibility.
  4. Confirm loan size against limits. For 2026, the FHFA conforming loan limit baseline for one-unit homes is $832,750. Most Virginia localities, including Henrico and Chesterfield counties, use that baseline, while high-cost Northern Virginia localities such as Fairfax County follow a higher ceiling up to $1,249,125. Verify your county before relying on either figure.

The classic mistake is comparing a HELOC’s introductory rate against a fixed cash-out rate. HELOC rates are variable. Stress test the row: if the $50,000 line moves from 8.5% to 10.5%, interest-only payments rise from about $354 to about $437 a month. Ask for current HELOC rate ranges from the lender, and model the higher scenario.

What to measure: blended interest rate and total monthly payment under each path, including the stressed HELOC case.

7. Score the Non-Dollar Factors

Some of the costliest differences between quotes never appear in a fee line. A quote that wins by $15 a month, but demands a hard credit pull, locks your rate for only 15 days, and charges a few hundred dollars per extension, can cost you more than it saves. Over 35 months, $15 a month is just $525.

Add a scored section to the sheet, rating each option from 1 to 5 on:

Weight the categories by what matters to you. If you are closing against a deadline, give timeline and lock length more weight. Combine the weighted score with the dollar rows, and use a soft-pull pre-qualification to start so gathering quotes does not cost you points on your credit report.

Here is how an assembled sheet might look, using the opening illustration:

RowCurrent loanOffer A: 30-year, 6.0%Offer B: 30-year, 6.0%, higher feesOffer C: 20-year, 6.0%
Months remaining or new term336360360240
Monthly principal and interest$2,175$1,919$1,919$2,293
Monthly change vs. currentNone$256 lower$256 lower$118 higher
Out-of-pocket closing costsNone$7,000$8,800$7,000
Break-even monthNot applicable2835Not applicable, payment rises
Interest remaining or total interest$410,800$370,700$370,700$230,200
Interest plus closing costs$410,800$377,700$379,500$237,200
Non-dollar score (1 to 5, your weights)Not applicableFill inFill inFill in

The mistake here is letting a tiny payment difference override lock risk or a slow close. What to measure: your weighted score alongside the dollar rows, plus lock-extension cost and days to close for each quote.

Refinance Comparison Worksheet Questions, Answered Straight

What is a refinance comparison worksheet?

A refinance comparison worksheet is a side-by-side sheet that lists your current loan and each refinance offer on identical rows: rate, APR, points, fees, payment, term, total interest, break-even month, and non-dollar factors. It converts several quotes into directly comparable numbers.

How do I calculate the break-even month on a refinance?

Divide your total out-of-pocket closing costs by your true monthly savings. If costs are $6,500 and savings are $190, break-even is about 34 months. Include any costs rolled into the loan when you work out the savings.

How long should a refinance take to break even?

There is no universal cutoff. Break-even should land comfortably inside the time you expect to keep the loan, with a cushion in case plans change. A 28-month break-even works for a ten-year owner and fails for someone moving in two years.

Does a lower interest rate always mean I will save money?

No. A lower rate can be offset by fees, a longer term, or a short holding period. In the opening illustration, a drop from 7.0% to 6.0% saved money after month 28 but lost money for someone leaving at month 24.

What is a Loan Estimate and how do I compare two of them?

A Loan Estimate is a standardized three-page disclosure of your loan terms and costs, explained by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Request them on the same day with the same lock period, then compare rate, APR, and Sections A, B, and C line by line.

Are discount points worth paying when I refinance?

They pay off only if you keep the loan past the point’s break-even. A point costing $3,200 that saves $60 a month needs about 53 months. If you may sell or refinance sooner, a lender-credit option is usually safer.

Should I roll closing costs into my new loan?

Rolling costs in reduces cash at closing but raises your balance and payment, so break-even still counts them. Model both versions on the sheet and compare the true monthly savings.

Is a cash-out refinance or a HELOC cheaper?

It depends on your current first-mortgage rate and how much you borrow. Compare the blended rate and total payment for each path, and stress test the HELOC’s variable rate. Conventional cash-out is capped at 90% LTV; VA cash-out can reach 100% LTV.

Will getting quotes hurt my credit?

A soft-pull pre-qualification does not affect your credit score. A hard pull is generally needed to get a full quote or lock, and scoring models typically treat mortgage inquiries made within a short window as a single inquiry.

Is Duane Buziak a mortgage broker or a mortgage lender?

Both. Duane Buziak is a mortgage broker who shops hundreds of wholesale lenders to find the right fit for your loan, and he also has in-house and correspondent funding capability when that structure serves you better.

Where to Start When the Sheet Is Still Blank

Begin with the baseline and the break-even rows, items 1 and 3. They eliminate weak offers faster than anything else, because a quote that cannot break even inside your holding period does not need further study. Once a few offers survive, run the term-reset and points rows to refine the survivors, since those two decide whether a good-looking payment is actually good for the life of the loan. The cash-out, HELOC, and scoring rows come last, and only matter if you want equity or the final two quotes are close.

You do not have to fill in the sheet with guesses. Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647, can run real numbers against your statement and give you comparable quotes. Ready to discover how much you could save with Virginia’s top-ranked mortgage expert? Call (804) 212-8663 now for your free soft-pull rate analysis: no credit impact, no obligation. Find out if refinancing can lower your monthly payments or unlock your home’s equity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *